Yes, the title is somewhat abstruse – but I, along with other university choristers, sang an interesting work by that name at the 1974 Intervarsity Choral Festival in Adelaide.
Anyway, as it seems to have been Friday forever, I thought it might be appropriate to reflect on last night’s fascinating Q&A, with the aid of ǢRCHIE’S ARCHIVE.
Empirical Discussion of Malcolm Roberts
Some of us have heard Senator-Elect Malcolm Roberts using the word ‘Empirical’ on numerous occasions.
Last night a whole lot more got to hear him use the word many times during the ABC show, Q&A.
Just what does the word mean and why is it at odds with much of what most scientists say and believe?
The Oxford Online Dictionary has the following definition.

So what Roberts is saying is that you cannot predict anything. If you see something happen and cause an outcome then you can explain it but you cannot use that event to conclude that should the same thing happen again that the outcome will be the same.
So scientists should never predict what MAY happen as a result of certain current conditions.
In Malcolm Roberts’ world anything to do with climate change is unprovable and so should be ignored because it relies on another long word.

In the Malcolm Roberts Universe it seems that any extrapolation is badly unscientific. I won’t insult my readers by quoting examples where we extrapolate outcomes from current data every day. In life or death situations which we simply take for granted. Tried crossing a busy street between traffic lately?
Malcolm, your repetitive use of the word ‘Empirical’ does not show you to be a knowledgeable scientist.
I note that your degree is in Engineering. Applied Science. The lesser brother of Theoretical Science. Yes, you can build stuff, you can play with Meccano with impeccable skill. Yet you have not learnt the skills that are Science. You have not developed a theory from repeated and repeatable experiments. You seem to show little understanding of that essential scientific method.
Every scientific theory relies on extrapolation.
A scientific theory is not something dreamed up at 2am by a group of bored people. It is an explanation garnered from empirical evidence discovered through experimentation, extrapolated within the theory to a predictable outcome then discussed, torn to pieces and accepted or rejected on the evidence and on the logic by others who also know the subject. That is what peer review is all about. Yes, theories do change around the edges but once accepted they are surprisingly robust. Even Newton’s three Laws of Thermodynamics still hold despite the tinkering Einstein provided with his theory of relativity.
I’m sorry, Malcolm, you do not convince anyone with any knowledge of science.
You are just a passing thorn in the side of progress.

fiona
Lovely intro video. It brought memories back. One such memory is Juliette Gréco’s version:
Or he will hold his breath until he turns blue ? lol:
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2016/aug/16/malcolm-turnbull-demands-support-from-opposition-for-savings-measures
A koala having a tantrum. Very funny video:
http://www.magic1059.com.au/breakfast-show/matt-and-gracie/breakfast-blog/51332-viral-video-koala-gets-kicked-out-of-tree-and-throws-adorable-tantrum
Stuff’em . Moe pairing bastardry from that lot of peicks. Payback time.
https://www.google.com.au/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=5&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiJvKXg8sbOAhUBW5QKHUd0Bm0QFgg1MAQ&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.news.com.au%2Fnational%2Fpm-must-act-against-thomson-abbott%2Fstory-e6frfkvr-1226120910740&usg=AFQjCNFQPcU67zh0TlRkVqdDlUO0KpE6Ww
.
Good morning Dawn Patrollers. Today there is a monster cartoon supplement.
Turnbull will today announce an omnibus bill collecting all the savings that coincide with what Labor had included in its election costings.
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/tough-choices-malcolm-turnbull-ramps-up-pressure-to-back-6b-in-savings-20160816-gqttbn.html
Labor’s going to play hardball with the finely balanced parliament.
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/labor-to-play-hardball-with-pairing-and-test-governments-working-majority-20160816-gqtqwi.html
Ben Eltham on Turnbull’s maladies.
https://newmatilda.com/2016/08/16/the-symptoms-of-malcolm-turnbulls-maladies/
Michelle Grattan says that an out of touch Turnbull has a long way to run yet with the banking story.
https://theconversation.com/the-banking-story-has-a-way-to-run-for-malcolm-turnbull-64010
David Tyler on Turnbull’s growing list of catastrophes.
https://independentaustralia.net/article-display/tthe-2016-census-brandis-diarynauru-and-other-turnbull-catastrophes,9356
MUST READ! Ross Gittins ramps up the sarcasm index to 10.
http://www.smh.com.au/comment/big-business-has-had-it-tough-for-too-long-just-ask-them-20160815-gqtblg.html
More than anything this proposal reeks of Liberal ideology. It should be blocked.
http://www.smh.com.au/business/comment-and-analysis/is-the-door-already-closing-on-australias-recently-announced-open-data-policy-20160816-gqtvi4.html
Michael West dives deeper into the proposal.
http://www.michaelwest.com.au/asic-fees-rampant/
The Gosford church (sort of) reaches out to Pauline Hanson.
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/pauline-how-about-lunch-promuslim-church-reaches-out-to-one-nation-20160816-gqtksw.html
This will test Barnaby Joyce’s unparalleled skills.
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/barnaby-joyce-to-host-dairy-symposium-in-late-august-amid-industry-crisis-20160816-gqtzpd.html
Section 2 . . .
The public service union is targeting Michaela cash for failing to engage in good faith.
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/national/public-service/failure-to-engage-in-good-faith-public-service-union-targets-minister-michaelia-cash-20160816-gqtr7l.html
Some difficulties emerge for senior police at the Lindt inquiry.
http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/last-explosive-days-of-lindt-inquest-raise-questions-about-nsw-police-leadership-20160816-gqtp2k.html
Where being well endowed in the dick department is a distinct disadvantage. Have a look!
http://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/2016/08/16/inconvenient-penis-is-a-huge-problem-for-japanese-pole-vaulter-h/?utm_hp_ref=au-homepage
Trump seeks out the very best to assist his campaign.
http://www.smh.com.au/world/us-election/ousted-fox-news-chief-roger-ailes-is-advising-donald-trump-ahead-of-presidential-debates-20160816-gqu4to.html
A group of Republican foreign policy experts say that a Trump presidency would be a disaster for stability in Asia. Google.
/news/politics/world/us-election-donald-trump-a-disaster-for-asia-stability-20160816-gqtka4
Yes, the media are biased against Trump but that’s because he mostly tells lies.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/aug/16/media-bias-against-donald-trump-lies
The pressure is coming from everywhere on Turnbull to get active on the Nauru situation.
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/call-summit-on-nauru-manus-island-malcolm-turnbull-urged-20160816-gqtlqi.html
It’s getting hard to tell whether certain conservatives are trolls or are for real.
https://newmatilda.com/2016/08/16/its-getting-hard-to-tell-which-conservatives-are-trolling-and-which-are-for-real/
At parliament school with the new MPs.
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/first-day-at-school-for-new-mps-20160816-gqtq82.html
What on EARTH is BMW doing here? Looks like fully blown disgraceful conduct to me.
http://www.smh.com.au/business/want-a-bmw-no-disposable-income-no-problem–have-a-loan-anyway-20160815-gqswtd.html
Section 3 . . .
Tony Wright with a pen picture of the Senator from Wonderland – Malcolm Roberts.
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-opinion/the-new-senator-from-wonderland-dons-his-special-aluminium-helmet-20160816-gqth4d.html
The knife is set to come out to cut hundreds of jobs from Immigration and Border Force. Let’s see what chaos this “efficiency dividend” brings.
http://www.smh.com.au/national/public-service/hundreds-more-jobs-to-go-at-immigration-and-border-force-20160816-gqtokg.html
The history of the far right in Australia.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/aug/16/between-the-bomb-and-the-ballot-box-the-history-of-the-far-right-in-australia
An implosion is imminent at the Brisbane Lions Football Club.
http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/leigh-matthews-set-to-walk-out-on-brisbane-lions-as-coach-justin-leppitsch-set-to-lose-job-20160816-gqu1oj.html
Section 4 . . . Cartoon Corner Part 1
Dutton sends a message to refugees – Ron Tandberg.










Ron Tandberg with the Gosford church invitation to Hanson.
An eight part series on Neoliberal Health Care from Mark David.
Section 5 . . . Cartoon Corner Part 2
Cathy Wilcox and Anti-Science Week.





This one from Cathy Wilcox is telling! I wonder it there’s an angry white male under that hood.
A ripper from David Rowe here.
A sorrowful cartoon from Jordan.
David Pope and the Life of Brian (Cox).
Section 6 . . . Cartoon Corner Part 3
Warren Brown and NSW infrastructure.

Alan Moir with Morrison’s superannuation woes.
http://www.smh.com.au/photogallery/federal-politics/cartoons/alan-moir-20150921-gjrcxr.html
Mark Knight – Canberra comes to the aid of dairy farmers.
http://cdn.newsapi.com.au/image/v1/01ddf47bb23cd824bc873c1fb8a2c184
Rod Clement at yesterday’s visit to Murray-Goulburn.
http://cdn.newsapi.com.au/image/v1/742371f0b0ef17952267cfe7fcd41665?width=650
Bill Leak with David Leyonhjelm at QandA.
http://cdn.newsapi.com.au/image/v1/6dff26ad744c14385da9e2a130a93342?width=1024
MUST WATCH! The video on the census debacle shown on Insiders last Sunday.
http://thenewdaily.com.au/news/national/2016/08/15/census-independence-day/
Pyne’s lying whining about pairs is already getting tiresome.
Labor IS NOT denying sick leave or family leave to anyone. Labor is saying they will not provide a pair for a government MP who is taking that sort of leave. This is perfectly OK, legal, legitimate, whatever you want to call it because the pairs thing only applies during a hung parliament. Fizza has spent a lot of time boating about his ‘solid majority’ so the Fizza government does not qualify for pairs.
Maybe Chrissie and Fizza should spend a bit of time together occasionally, have a bit of a chat now and then, enjoy a man-date, do some collaboration so they can get their lies coordinated.
Brilliant collection today, BK.
Good to see Barnarby Joyce using the phrase I predicted yesterday, when he said “Two wrongs don’t make a right” in reference to Labor’s reluctance on pairing, this morning on ABC radio.
With Chris Pyne’s comments on pairing, and Abbott’s condemnation of “petty partisan politics” last week, we have come full circle in La-La-Land.
They think we are stupid. They think we can’t remember anything that happened before 8 this morning. They think they can just open their mouths and spout garbage and we will believe it all.
They can think again .
At last a senate cartoon that does not feature HER same mob though
Explaining the cartoon form Jordan –
http://rock.ly/cy5ok
Leone
Unfortunately too many in Aussie do forget, or don’t pay attention, which has always been the way. The msm are the worst culprits.
More trouble for Fizza and Sprout
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2016/aug/17/this-is-critical-103-nauru-and-manus-staff-speak-out-their-letter-in-full
Going to prosecute all of them?
Seems to have escaped the attention of Their ABC
They do, however, have this about the boats not having stopped
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-17/boat-carrying-sri-lankans-intercepted/7750474
All the usual stuff about pairing being regurgitated… “Labor should know better”, “Time to end the mindless partisanship”, “Two wrongs don’t make a right”, “Unfair work practices”, “Petty payback” etc. across the various tabloids and News Ltd outlets… plus the ABC of course.
It’s not so much that Pyne et al can’t remember anything that happened before 8am, it’s that they rely on the Media to put this rubbish out as incontrovertible truth.
I, for one, am sick of Labor being expected to be the moral lighthouse of Australian politics, and then marked down if they are not. When they were the victims of Abbott’s pairing tactics, they were “hapless”, “disorganized”, “shambolic” and so on.
Whether dishing it out, or on the receiving end of Coalition political dirty play Labor are always losers in the eyes of the Media.
May as well be hung for a sheep as a goat. Sick ’em Bill.
Seems Frank Elly “lost it” with Chris Bowen this morning.
Anyone know?
Listen here –
http://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/breakfast/labor's-approach-to-budget-repair-to-'reflect/7750666
BK
Haven’t read the article, but playing the Tim Minchin video for about the 100th time, it is fantastic.
Will George be well enough to answer questions?
Well enough to say he can’t remember.
Those gumboots should always remain locked up in the back shed, Bill
tlbd
Haven’t seen anything on twitter about it, maybe all the ones I follow have given up on RN as well. I see a couple of people are saying the same as I said to Razz the other day with Jon Faine, he hasn’t talked Fed politics for ages now, his re-education camp was obviously a success.
tlbd
Here’s this mornings interview with Bowen……..I’ll listen to it now.
http://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/breakfast/labor's-approach-to-budget-repair-to-'reflect/7750666
Liberals are doing their usual conclusion-based-on-false-premise routine. They claim their budget cuts will build the economy based on nothing other than their claims. Without bothering to stop for a second to justify what they intend to do, they move on to the ALP’s ‘duty’ to pass the cuts for the good of the economy.
The ALP will rightly want all this more closely looked at, and the Liberal response will be that the ALP are being obstructionist.
Labor can just throw back a wonderful Abbott quote if/when they refuse to back this legislation –
“That was then, this is now”.
Or Shorten could use the John Howard backflipping on the GST excuse –
“I have changed my mind”
https://pmtranscripts.dpmc.gov.au/release/transcript-10756
Keep throwing their own words and actions back at them.
tlbd
Nup, nothing unusual about that interview, she was her nasty belligerent self, now I’ll go and have a shower and brush my teeth again to get the bad smell off me.
The call for milk to be handed out to kids in schools is a blast from the past.
As a kid in the 50s I went to a bush school with an enrollment of about 20 or less, about 20 miles from the “big town” that was the administrative hub of the district. Our milk came from Goulburn, about 150 miles away to a distribution point at the big town from whence a truck (uncovered) distributed it to the schools in the town and the 30 or so small schools dotted around the district, some of which were even smaller than ours. Deliveries started about 8:00 am and our school was near the end of the circuitous route so we got ours about 1:00pm. In summer time the glass bottles were almost too hot to touch from their exposure to the sun, and often the teachers would insist that the milk be thrown out as it had curdled.
We were all brought up on farms and so were never in need of the benefits of free milk, our family regularly milked 2 or 3 cows for our house and for the use of our employees and others who needed it. However the flavouring of the milk added to its attraction and so it was seldom refused.
School milk is the worst memory of my school days.
The stuff came in miniature milk bottles, was delivered before dawn, stacked in crates behind one of the portables, uncovered, and then left to bake in the sun until 11 o’clock then served up warm and almost sour. It was plain milk, not flavoured. We were forced to drink it. My siblings and I had plenty of milk at home but like all the other parents back then mum refused to write notes to get us out of drinking the revolting school stuff. Parents were not as indulgent and pampering of their offspring as they are now.
School milk continued to plague me when I started teaching. It was up to me to force little kids to drink their milk. There was a brief respite when I taught at Ballina for 6 months. The milk there came from Norco, was flavoured, delivered about 9 in the morning and stored in a special refrigerated area. The kids loved it and always hoped for seconds.
In Griffith the milk came in little plastic bags. The milk monitors had to snip off a corner, then a straw was inserted. You can imagine what a bunch of boisterous little boys liked to do with their little bags of milk. The flavours were revolting. Banana milk, anyone?
Gough Whitlam killed off free school milk in 1973 and teachers everywhere were immensely thankful.
Some years ago we had a milkman deliver the milk in bottles. I never felt it was really fresh. I gave it up.
At school in winter we had a hot chocolate and a REM biscuit which was delicious.
I remain psychologically damaged from being forced to drink warm milk at school in the early 1950s.
I had forgotten about the banana flavoured milk. It was disgusting and of course bore no resemblance to the taste of an actual banana.
Heh! Kelly O’Bigmouth has the boot on the other foot… and it’s shoved firmly in her mouth:
Suddenly depriving MPs of a pair is “a game”, presumably one that only children play, or are victims of.
How sweet it is.
Have a stab at why, Kelly.
Getting lost in all the chatter about pairs is something else that will really hurt the Fizza government.
Labor has refused to provide anyone for the Speaker’s panel. This means the government will have to provide all the deputy speakers for this term of government. That’s going to hurt that ‘solid majority’ when Mr Speaker has to take time off to attend to official business.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-17/labor-to-put-parliamentary-majority-to-test/7750250
“At school in winter we had a hot chocolate and a REM biscuit which was delicious.”
Looxury!
I remember it with fondness and gratitude. And of course with nostalgia …
What about the chemical fake strawberry flavouring ‘saturated’ in the straw if that was your want?
Did milk & ink monitors eventually end up as CEO’s of corporations?
At my primary school the milk monitors were real stand-over boys. They probably became prison warders. The ink monitors were grossly incompetent. They had to mix up the ink themselves, using a powder and water, they never managed to get it right. It was either so watery it was useless, or so thick it clogged up our nibs. I think with that ability to stuff up a simple task they grew up to be either CEOs or conservative politicians.
School milk was only a problem for us in that it used to freeze in the bottles in winter if it wasn’t carted into the canteen. Wasn’t so bad in the early summer months, but then England was slightly cooler back in the day.
Mrs Thatcher stopped the school milk ration in the 60s when she was the education minister, she also amalgamated my girls grammar school into a co-ed comprehensive that was horrible and for which my parents never forgave her. (I think they were glad to be in Australia while she was PM.)
Just look at the photo Pauline Hanson has chosen for her official parliamentary listing.
It must have been taken a long, long time ago!
It’s obviously recycled from her last stint in parliament in 1996. The green background is a real giveaway, all the other senators have red backgrounds.
http://www.aph.gov.au/Senators_and_Members/Senators/Senators_photos
Didn’t she look pretty then !!
there are a lot of OLD pictures there, some have been recycled though many years in politics so Pauline is no exception and as said her background is a give away. Not much thought went into it.
Just had a flying trip into A&E, to have the canula replaced. It was amazing we wouldn’t have been there more than ten minutes. We can believe it was so quick. Have to go back Sunday for them to see if she needs to continue. We asked what would be a good time and the nurse said 8am.
On the drive we in had to turn radio off because Fizza was making awful noises out of his mouth. On the way home had Toolman on, I started ranting and Razz told me to stfu, so I did, and to our surprise he was laughing about them turning the sound off when the woman was protesting, then apparently the turned the lights off while Fizza was still talking. Then toolman said wtte, it didn’t matter anyway we’ve heard it all before. There was the ‘plan’ but nothing about what is in the plan, etc etc etc. We were both gobsmacked.
Correction, second sentence, We could not believe it how quick it was.
I think Barnaby’s a bit sulky about the pairing thing because it means he can’t have a couple of bottles of red before a major vote without risking the government losing votes on the floor.
Here’s hoping Labor is merciless with this. But not too merciless of course, the look of a Coalition MP having to be in the house with a drip attached to them for a major vote probably won’t be good and will be howled about by the CPG.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2016/aug/17/manus-island-detention-centre-to-close-australia-and-papua-new-guinea-agree
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-11/australia-brings-in-second-refugee-agency-on-cambodia-deal/7718334 from 11 August
Leone
Any chance you could could copy Bernard Keane’s article into the blog?
“Labor should be totally disruptive — here’s the theory that explains why”
Paul Bongiorno tweeted it and it looks interesting, but paywalled..
Here it is –
Labor should be totally disruptive — here’s the theory that explains why
https://www.crikey.com.au/2016/08/17/keane-on-why-labor-should-disrupt-parliament/
Thanks!
https://www.crikey.com.au/2016/08/17/keane-on-why-labor-should-disrupt-parliament/
Yes the above is paywalled, but if you want to get the gist, read the below 2011 article he refers back to. Its now free, and goes into plenty of detail on the concept.
https://www.crikey.com.au/2011/08/15/what-game-theory-says-about-labors-woes/
Long Tan: Vietnamese authorities cancel 50th anniversary commemoration event, DFAT says
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-17/vietnam-police-block-access-to-long-tan-site/7756984
Lots of others around Australia (too many to post here); follow this link to see what’s up, where:
http://www.airforce.gov.au/Operations/Flying-Operations/?RAAF-hPR1ZyeqIMWKiaNtrjPMdufiX/RBJSoR
Anyone else see the disgusting footage of Fizza giving money to a beggar?
“Give”? Leased, surely.
Tax deductible?
A lousy $5. Not as much as he is about to cut out of Newstart.
Long Tan? I’m with the Vietnamese.
For obvious reasons, they don’t want ceremony but are willing for small groups and individual people to visit the memorial.
Agreed. The restrictions seemed quite reasonable, as did the “friendship dinner” between the veterans of both sides.
1000 people plus a concert – WTF?! Did the “Camp Long Tan” mob get involved?
Skippy didn’t cover himself in glory at the time of the Lindt affair.
One example: wtte “we should do so-and-so but it’s up to you”. Then, denying, before the coroner, that he did not think that was “as close as you can get to a command.”
7.5 is doing a good summary of the Lindt thingy.
Good to see they waited till all the submissions and interviews are over.
Skippy and Bambi not looking good.
This Is Why There Are So Many Ties In Swimming
http://regressing.deadspin.com/this-is-why-there-are-so-many-ties-in-swimming-1785234795
A tolerance of 3 cms and measuring to a thousands of a second.
Can’t see the problem. Nor, it seems, can bods running swimming events.
3cm WTF. With that sort of margin of error they must think the Coalition builds them
Researchers orbit a muon around an atom, confirm physics is broken
http://arstechnica.com/science/2016/08/researchers-orbit-a-muon-around-an-atom-confirm-physics-is-broken/