Boiling Water – 21st Century Fascism

From this article here: https://www.the-reframe.com/boiling-water/

Imagine you have a friend. Let’s call him Rick Reasonable.

Now imagine you have an enemy. Let’s call your enemy Bart B. Oilingwater.

Bart is a real piece of crap. Whenever he sees you, he throws boiling water at you. Usually you dodge it, but every once in a while, he catches you with a bit. You have some bad scarring on one arm, and a few places on your face and neck. And you have to constantly be on the lookout for Bart, because if you let your guard down, it’s scalding water time!

Rick is a good friend. He thinks it is really bad that Bart throws boiling water on you. He tells you this all the time. He’s written some letters to the newspaper about how bad Bart is for throwing boiling water on you. Sometimes he’ll even go out with you to watch your back. He’s got a popular TV show, and he’s gone on the record a few times that Bart is in the wrong for always trying to hit you in the face with boiling water.

Then one day you turn on the TV at the end of the day, and you see Rick has Bart on as a guest. Rick is arguing with Bart about whether or not it is good to douse you with boiling water at every available opportunity. Rick is … parsing things a little more than you’d like.

He wants to know if the water has to be boiling, if it can’t just be very hot. Bart says, no, no, it really does have to be boiling. But does it have to be water, Rick asks. Could it be something a bit easier to dodge, like molasses or tar? Bart thinks about this, and decides he isn’t sure. He’ll have to get back to Rick on that one—but really, he prefers water.

Rick wants to know if there can’t be days Bart could promise to not throw boiling water at you. Bart doesn’t really want to set that sort of precedent.

Rick would like to know why it needs to be you every time. Bart is shocked that Rick would suggest such a thing. He insists he doesn’t have a throwing-boiling-water-on-you-specifically bone in his body. He just believes in throwing boiling water, and you happen to be the one that’s there every time. He’d like to know why, if you apparently hate being struck with boiling water, you insist on being in areas where you know he will be throwing it. He suggests that Rick is really the one singling him, Bart, out, by being so intolerant of his rich cultural heritage of throwing boiling water on people. He hints that Rick’s constant scolding makes Bart want to seek you out specifically now, to throw boiling water on you, for daring to suppose such a thing of him.

Rick appears to have conceded that Bart absolutely does have a right to walk the streets carrying as much boiling water as he wants, in the long-standing tradition of our country. Bart appreciates Rick’s stance on the matter, and compliments him on his willingness to find common ground.

At the end of the segment, he and Bart agree to disagree on whether or not it is good to attempt to douse you with boiling water every day. Bart still thinks it is very good—though he insists it is not directed at you, but only at spaces that you happen to inhabit. He wonders, again, why you choose to inhabit those spaces. Rick continues to insist that throwing at the space that you inhabit is tantamount to throwing it at you, and that it is quite rude indeed. They shake hands. Then there is a commercial for Pepsi.

The next day, you confront Rick about this and he shrugs. “Man, I hate that bastard Bart,” he says, “but you have to hear both sides.”

How are we feeling about Rick?

344 thoughts on “Boiling Water – 21st Century Fascism

  1. Have not seen anywhere but twitter yet but looks like first federal YouGov of the term at 56-44. 16% of 2022 Coalition voters now say they would vote for One Nation.

    Kevin Bonham (@kevinbonham.bsky.social) 2025-09-29T23:53:51.325Z

    I hadn't seen George Brandis' op ed about expanding parliament but it is indeed completely false and @benraue.com has kindly saved me the trouble of debunking it http://www.tallyroom.com.au/62130

    Kevin Bonham (@kevinbonham.bsky.social) 2025-09-30T00:04:59.566Z

    The Trump administration will proceed with the AUKUS defense pact linking the U.S., U.K. and Australia, maintaining the original timeline that includes the sale of three Virginia-class submarines to Canberra beginning in 2032, Nikkei Asia has learned. archive.is/k9RBm #auspol #ausdef

    Leroy (@leroylynch.bsky.social) 2025-09-30T07:43:38.974Z

  2. Blair would help oversee Gaza transition under Trump plan

    1 hour ago

    That shameless piece of shit Tony Blah should be in the Hague on trial. 😦

  3. Guardian Essential poll: Australians back emissions target while One Nation support doubles

    https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2025/oct/01/australians-back-labor-albanese-emissions-target-while-one-nation-support-doubles-guardian-essential-poll

    Here is the Essential federal poll referred to in the Guardian article. First, the voting figures are always on this separate page (and now show for the first time since the election).

    https://essentialreport.com.au/reports/federal-political-insights

    TTP+: ALP 51 L/NP 44
    Primary: ALP 35 L/NP 27 GRN 11 ON 13 IND/OTH 9 UAP 2 Undecided 6

    TPP and Primary figures don’t exclude undecided, so they will seem lower and can’t be face value compared to other polls like Newspoll and Morgan.

    The new Report with all the issues questions is here.

    https://essentialreport.com.au/reports/30-september-2025

  4. #Essential primaries in theory not on same scale as other polls because undecided left in. ALP 35 L-NP 27 Green 11 ON 13 TOP 2 IND/other 6 undecided 6 Their "2PP+" by respondent prefs ALP leads 51-44 (=53.7)My 2025 prefs estimate 56.2 to ALP

    Kevin Bonham (@kevinbonham.bsky.social) 2025-09-30T21:55:17.355Z

    In theory Essential's primaries should on average all be a bit lower than other polls because they leave undecided in. But what tends to happen in practice is they have IND/other way too low and the rest look more like other polls.

    Kevin Bonham (@kevinbonham.bsky.social) 2025-09-30T21:57:00.451Z

    Essential's "2PP+" method also persistently produces weird preference flows (this one implausibly weak for Labor). Overall Essential has ranked poorly compared to other polls in recent years.

    Kevin Bonham (@kevinbonham.bsky.social) 2025-09-30T22:00:43.772Z

    What is happening in the last-election-preferences 2PP race lately: nothing. ALP still dominant at 56.2 with very little movement since polling resumed (the bump up into the 57s in early-mid July was basically one poll)

    Kevin Bonham (@kevinbonham.bsky.social) 2025-09-30T22:41:18.953Z

    SMH: ‘A pivotal moment’: In Sydney, Inner West Council, led by Labor Mayor Darcy Byrne, backs plans for up to 30,000 new homes web.archive.org/web/20250930… #nswpol

    Leroy (@leroylynch.bsky.social) 2025-10-01T01:05:54.228Z

    I suggest that the 2020s version of this Right Wing comedian phenomenon is the Riyadh festival. There is also something akin to the failed or declining mainstream politician or personality hooking themselves into the populist right grifting machine about it. http://www.theguardian.com/culture/2025...

    Leroy (@leroylynch.bsky.social) 2025-09-30T23:34:47.212Z

  5. PM says scheme will have ‘minimal impact’ on prices

    Albanese says 5% deposit scheme about young people ‘realising dream of home ownership’

    There is an aroma of bovine excrement with a dash of snake oil in the air. In a market with a shortage of supply a jump in demand will do what Albo ? Or is the ‘minimal impact’ prediction based on the knowledge that in the great scheme of things the numbers involved will be sfa ?

    • I was very happy when that Argentine loon was elected. Bad news for the poor buggers who live in Argentina though. Mind you they were already up shit creek without a paddle before he was elected. So I can understand their ‘fuck it ! Let’s wreck the joint”.

      I was overjoyed because he was nut job enough to actually implement the hard core economic bullshit of the likes of arsehole Milton Friedman that we keep being told by the ‘Ruperts’ and lots of Coalition polies is THE way to go to reach economic nirvana.

      But not a word needs to be read, anyone doing happy snaps with this monster can ‘foad’.

  6. Albo looks like he’ll gets the gig for prepping us for the traditional handing control of our resources to foreign interests. There are a lot of deposits of this stuff around the world but for good reason few countries bother much with then. It is a filthy industry that produces enormous amounts of toxic waste.

    —————————————————————————————————————————–
    Donald Trump ‘aggressively’ pivoting towards Australian critical minerals to shut down China monopoly

    The US interest comes ahead of Anthony Albanese’s meeting with President Donald Trump later this month.
    https://thewest.com.au/politics/federal-politics/donald-trump-aggressively-pivoting-towards-australian-critical-minerals-to-shut-down-china-monopoly-c-20213443

    “It was evident that they see Australia as a reliable ally

    I suspect he has misunderstood what being a ‘reliable ally’ of the US actually means. This Chinese cartoon from the comrades had it right.

    CARTOON
    No.1 lackey
    https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202112/1241035.shtml

  7. Trump has been reading the sacred texts , you know, Mien Kampf etc etc… He must have been sooo tempted to say ‘Untermensch’ in the last quote below

    “It’s a war from within.Trump prepares the generals for what comes next

    The American left: “They’re really bad. They’re bad people.”
    …….. domestic political opponents: “They’re vicious people that we have to fight, just like you have to fight vicious people. Mine are a different kind of vicious.”…….

    .American journalists: “sleazebags.”

    US cities should be military training grounds, Trump tells generals

    …………..Residents of American inner cities: “animals.”

     Hitler’s growing preoccupation with “the enemy withinon the eve of the Final Solution. British Intelligence sensed this happening.

    https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/inside-hitlers-mind

  8. The Australian: Andrew Hastie quits Sussan Ley’s frontbench over refusal to give him a role in migration policy work archive.is/LzgNy #auspol

    Leroy (@leroylynch.bsky.social) 2025-10-03T09:57:19.485Z

    My Financial Times interview got reprinted on the front page of the newspaper The Australian Financial Review with an incredible illustration of the contents of my mind and the big handle I turn when I blog http://www.afr.com/technology/t...

    Ed Zitron (@edzitron.com) 2025-10-02T22:27:58.547Z

    The Coalition has always struggled to understand the difference between baseload power & firming. Dan Tehan has just returned from a "fact-finding" tour of the US & he's none the wiser. He holds Wannon on a 3.8% margin & is still pushing nuclear. #auspol reneweconomy.com.au?p=237347

    David Marler (@qldaah.bsky.social) 2025-10-02T20:00:45.958Z

  9. It’s looking like there’ll be a Liberal leadership spill on Tuesday when the House sits again.

    There’s no way Hastie would make such a move like this if he wasn’t told that he had the numbers to overthrow Ley.

    And even if he loses, he’ll just try again next year.

  10. For the next post, I’m thinking of posting an excerpt of 1984 by George Orwell, namely Part 3, Chapter 3.

    It’s chilling to read, especially in how much it relates to the MAGA movement.

    • In Nineteen Eighty-Four’s Part 3, Chapter 3, the torture of Winston by O’Brien culminates with O’Brien revealing the Party’s sole goal is absolute power for its own sake, not for any greater good. Winston is shown his emaciated, grey body in a mirror, a symbol of the Party’s success in crushing the human spirit. The chapter also details Winston’s entry into the “understanding” stage of reintegration and features O’Brien’s confession of collaborating on the supposed Goldstein book, further undermining Winston’s belief in the Brotherhood. 

  11. LibSpill ruled out this year. The winter break is the usual period for challenges. No doubt who Sarah Henderson is backing. Time now for Andrew Hastie & supporters to agitate on immigration. Perhaps travel around the country to get the numbers. #auspol http://www.skynews.com.au/opinion/outs...

    David Marler (@qldaah.bsky.social) 2025-10-05T02:13:38.622Z

    My personal favourite unparliamentary language is from the NZ parliament in 1949, when Labour’s Frank Langstone stated of National’s Ronald Algie that “his brains could revolve inside a peanut shell for a thousand years without touching the sides”: nzhistory.govt.nz/politics/his…

    André Brett (@drdrehistorian.bsky.social) 2025-10-04T22:11:08.879Z

    My latest in the @australia.theguardian.com isn’t just about how we must regulate tech – it’s about how WE CAN.#auspol http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre...

    Van Badham (@vanbadham.bsky.social) 2025-10-05T01:19:45.817Z

    10K Word Premium: OpenAI is another unprofitable, desperate AI startup building products on its own models, spending $2.60 to make $1. Sora 2 is a reckless attempt to grow ChatGPT that costs them at least $5 per generated video. They need to raise $20bn+ before EoY.www.wheresyoured.at/sora2-openai/

    Ed Zitron (@edzitron.com) 2025-10-03T16:48:17.672Z

    British reality TV has become a vehicle for reputational recovery, utilised increasingly by controversial and disgraced conservative figures hoping to wash away a bad public impression by making a lovable fool of themselves to audiences of millions. observer.co.uk/news/opinion…

    Leroy (@leroylynch.bsky.social) 2025-10-04T11:31:00.550Z

    "The wallpaper was busier maybe, the world was browner, but essentially it was the same world, where telephones were answered with a string of digits and time flowed begrudgingly forwards like gravy."I wrote about my favourite sitcom of all time.madeleinebrettingham.substack.com/p/that-is-wh…

    Madeleine Brettingham (@littlemaddles.bsky.social) 2025-10-02T08:06:40.306Z

  12. Police have arrested almost 500 people in London at what organisers hoped would be the biggest demonstration so far against a ban on the proscribed organisation Palestine Action.

    Officers began arresting demonstrators at the silent vigil in support of the group, which has been classed by the UK government as a terror organisation since July this year.

    The first arrest took place shortly after 1pm as the seated protesters took out pens and wrote signs showing support for Palestine Action.

    Dozens of police were lined up to begin arresting members of the group, who were sitting silently on the pavement in the square.

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/oct/04/palestine-action-protest-police-arrests-london-demo

    Terrorists!

  13. #Newspoll Fed poll TPP: ALP 57 (-1) L/NP 43 (+1) Primary: ALP 37 (+1) L/NP 28 (+1) GRN 12 (-1) ON 11 (+1) OTH 12 (-2) Preferred PM: Albanese 52 (+1) Ley 30 (-1) Albo: Approve 47 (+2) Disapprove 48 (-2) Ley: Approve 31 (-1) Disapprove 51 (+2) http://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/polit... ($) #auspol

    Leroy (@leroylynch.bsky.social) 2025-10-05T08:00:16.845Z

    https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/politics/newspoll-one-nation-surges-as-sussan-leys-net-approval-rating-plunges/news-story/bd1e89d2319827a5bb01ce6eb0888453

    Newspoll: One Nation surges, as Sussan Ley’s net approval rating plunges

    Support for One Nation has surged to its highest level since 2017, as Sussan Ley’s approval rating plunges and Labor records its strongest primary vote in 28 months.
    Geoff Chambers
    October 5, 2025 – 6:00PM

    Support for Pauline Hanson’s One Nation has surged to its highest level since 2017, as Sussan Ley’s approval rating plunges and Labor records its strongest primary vote in 28 months.

    An exclusive Newspoll conducted for The Australian reveals core support for the Coalition remains at near-record lows while One Nation’s primary vote rose to 11 per cent, which is almost double the minor party’s performance at the May 3 election.

    The Newspoll, which was in the field between Monday and Thursday last week before Andrew Hastie quit Ms Ley’s shadow cabinet, shows the Coalition’s primary vote remains at a historically low 28 per cent.

    The result is just one per cent higher than the 27 per cent in last month’s poll, which was the lowest level of support for the Liberals and Nationals since Newspoll first counted primary votes in ­November 1985.

    As Ms Ley battles to keep the Coalition united on key issues including migration, net zero by 2050 emissions and energy, the Opposition Leader’s net approval rating slid to minus 20, with 31 per cent of voters satisfied with her performance and 51 per cent dissatisfied.

    The poll of 1264 voters conducted ahead of house MPs and senators returning to parliament on Tuesday shows Labor’s core support rising to 37 per cent, which is the highest primary vote for the ALP since June 2023.

    With the Greens and Others category, which includes independents and minor parties, recording primary vote falls since last month’s Newspoll, Labor’s two-party-preferred vote lead over the Coalition dropped a point to 57 per cent to 43 per cent.

    Amid splits inside the ­Coalition over how to stop conservative votes bleeding to minor parties and independents, One Nation’s primary vote is now at its highest level since July 2017 when Malcolm Turnbull was prime minister. During Peter Dutton’s tenure as opposition leader, the highest primary vote recorded by One Nation was 8 per cent.

  14. “Amid splits inside the ­Coalition over how to stop conservative votes bleeding to minor parties and independents, One Nation’s primary vote is now at its highest level since July 2017 when Malcolm Turnbull was prime minister. During Peter Dutton’s tenure as opposition leader, the highest primary vote recorded by One Nation was 8 per cent.’

    With Dutton, the right-wingers had a hard choice: with Ley, their choice is easy.

  15. Sussan Ley faces emboldened conservative backbench after Hastie’s resignation, Liberal MPs warn

    They bring to mind this crew. They sure do seem to have a couple of squads of them.

  16. The chap who coined the word ‘enshittification‘ with an article we probably all can relate to.

    Way past its prime: how did Amazon get so rubbish?

    In 2022, I coined a term to describe the sudden-onset platform collapse going on all around us: enshittification. To my bittersweet satisfaction, that word is doing big numbers. In fact, it has achieved escape velocity. It isn’t just a way to say something got worse. It’s an analysis that explains the way an online service gets worse, how that worsening unfolds, and the contagion that’s causing everything to get worse, all at once.

    https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/oct/05/way-past-its-prime-how-did-amazon-get-so-rubbish

    • When asked to comment for this article, an Amazon spokesman said its description of the relationship between Amazon and independent sellers appeared to be “inacccurate and misleading”

      “appeared to be”?

      The description is, or is not, accurate.

      I’m guessing that it is not “inaccurate and misleading.” And Amazon thinks so too.

Comments are closed.