The Festival Hall Organ

Today’s Guest Author is the wonderful Gorgeous Dunny. Thank you so much for honouring The Pub again, GD!

[Recently I was asked to relate some of my political experiences, having worked and lived through the times of our more charismatic leaders of the 1960s and 1970s, Don Dunstan, Gough Whitlam and Bob Hawke. They transformed Australia’s outlook on things from a colonial outpost in the British Empire, to a broader view of the world and our role in it. In a current age where we’ve allowed parochialism, paranoia and selfishness to dominate the way we are governed, it may help to know that once we were led by vision and hope.]

This is the story of the purchase of Adelaide Festival Hall Organ and how a major philistine bunfight was avoided in doing so. The story involves two States and two major cultural buildings in their capital cities: the Sydney Opera House and the Adelaide Festival Centre. Firstly, it should be acknowledged that they are not strictly comparable. The Sydney Opera House is an architectural wonder of the world, a unique sails-like roof design looking out to the glorious Sydney Harbour and facing Circular Quay in the heart of Sydney. Its site at Bennelong Point had earlier been a tram barn.

The Festival Hall is modest by comparison, overlooking the Torrens Lake or River and the Adelaide Oval. It’s walking distance from Adelaide Railway Station and Parliament House. It was almost an accident of choice. Don Dunstan, who succeeded Frank Walsh as Labor Premier, and was determined on a Renaissance for Adelaide on lifestyle, had wanted a suitable ‘home’ for the Adelaide Festival of Arts (later to be known simply as the Adelaide Festival) rather than the various halls scattered around the city.

His first choice was Government House, the residence of the State’s Governor at North Terrace, on the Eastern side of King William Road, and backing on to the Military Parade Ground before joining the banks of the Torrens opposite Adelaide Oval. It was a superb location only walking distance from the Museum, Art Gallery, Library and University.

However, he lost the election in 1968 on gerrymandered boundaries, despite getting 54% of the vote. The incoming Liberal Government of Mr Steele Hall and able Attorney-General Robin Millhouse, was exceedingly embarrassed at winning government with a minority vote of around 46% and a minority of seats, relying on three independents to form a government. To their credit, they embarked on a series of reforms aiming to match the Dunstan zeal. It included such things as abortion law reform. Importantly, Hall realised that the voting system must be fairer if public confidence was to be maintained. At that time two thirds of the State’s population lived in metropolitan Adelaide. Yet the MP representation was exactly the opposite. Two thirds of the seats were in country SA, and only one third in the rapidly growing Adelaide metropolitan area. It had been going that way for years, but it only looked so blatantly disproportionate with post-WWII immigration.

The biggest obstacle for reforming the voting system were the Liberal & Country League’s (LCL) own conservative colleagues. The Upper House Legislative Council was even more gerrymandered than the House of Assembly. Members were elected via a strange alliance of property owners heavily tilted towards country zones and wealth. Voting was voluntary.

As another disincentive, the Legislative Council Electoral Roll was used for summoning people for jury service.  The office of Chief Secretary was also Government Leader in the Council and virtually Deputy Premier. It was held by Mr Ren De Garis.

He saw no advantage to the state in changing the LCL’s privileged position. He had no interest in changing the Upper House. In his own words, Upper House MPs, propertied people, represented the “permanent will of the people”. Nothing like these fly-by-nighters flitting in and out of jobs, living in rented accommodation or boarding.

The struggle for fairer voting representation was mostly between the progressive section of the LCL, and its more reactionary colleagues mostly in the Upper House. Dunstan stirred it along, referring to the outrage of the unfair election result through large public protests. But Labor was always likely to support a voting system that would almost guarantee their return to power. That was easy enough in the Lower House where they already had the most MPs.

Just a few progressive LCL MPs would get it through. The Upper House, where De Garis was in charge, was the real challenge. Labor had only a handful of MLCs. Hall and Millhouse had to win over nearly half of their LCL MPs to get the laws passed. To their great credit, they did that. It was that sort of time when members of the political parties could work together for the greater public good. Dunstan was thus assured of return to the position of Premier as soon as an election was held.

Knowing that reality, Hall and Millhouse worked hard to pass progressive social reforms in the hope of gaining voter support. It did not work out that way, despite some excellent legislation. They did make one change, however, which appealed to both sections of their Party. Government House would remain as it was. The new site for the Festival Centre would be in Elder Park near the Railway Station and Parliament House. The site had been until then a Migrant Hostel, albeit in shabby condition. A new Hostel was built at suburban Woodville.

The site, although covered by derelict old buildings and storehouses at that time, lost nothing in comparison to Government House. It still had a splendid outlook to the Torrens on one side, and the classical old buildings of Parliament and Adelaide Railway Station, plus easy access to transport or parking. Importantly it became a home for performing groups in theatre and music so that workshops and experimental exercises could be conducted. In the performing arts whether theatre, music or song, marionettes, dance… a critical component is the development of skills through training and experiment. Workshops and studios were available for such work. Craft support via make-up, costumes, set design and construction, technical through sound and lighting and through secretarial and publicity services. It could provide some sort of home or forum for almost anything creative.

Dunstan’s own lifestyle had given him an identity and affinity with the arts. When studying law, he supported himself through employment on radio and the stage as an actor. He retained his membership of the Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance throughout his political career. The ABC, as now a national broadcaster, was then very much a federation. It set up an elaborate studio at Collinswood which produced national TV programs, plus national radio via Classic-FM. Don was given his own program on lifestyle in suburban Adelaide. He argued the case strongly for a Mediterranean lifestyle.

In politics he set out immediately to transform people’s lives, aiming to end racial discrimination and for a better way of living, dropping SA’s ‘wowser’ types of attitudes to alcohol and recreation. It helped that he was an elegant speaker, a voice sounding ‘posh’ yet ready to talk and listen to anybody. He even learned Italian so that he could communicate better with many of his Italian-origin migrants. He was a founding President of Meals On Wheels, dedicated to providing meals to aged people in their own home. Though his political work often took him working into the small hours for reforms and helping people, he had two other passions. One was for anything to do with the arts. The other was for friends with interests in food, wine and stimulating company.

One of his great achievements (with excellent advice from Melbourne Labor ‘Participants’ Philip Adams, Barry Jones and John Button) on setting up the South Australian Film Corporation (SAFC) as a body with some independence of bureaucratic and political interference. Though Australian movie production was almost extinct by the 1960s, apart from a few successes in Melbourne, he was determined to establish it as a viable film industry, providing world-quality standards and the opportunities for employment with it. In that, SAFC had some remarkable successes in the 1970s and 80s. It was soon imitated by other States and private syndicates. Australia was a world player: small, yet exciting here and abroad. Picnic at Hanging Rock and Storm Boy were two standouts of many.

Dunstan had learned along his way to compartmentalise his primary interests so that his political and governing work did not overlap his encouraging the autonomy of the creative arts, nor his own recreational activities among close friends. He ran a very well-disciplined ministry which had clear objectives and kept well within budgetary limits. However, his determination to let the creative arts flourish fully without interference led to one major problem at the Festival Centre. In the main performance hall a decision was made to purchase an elaborate organ for feature performance at opera and musical concerts.

It was no ordinary organ, as you might expect in a new Centre. It was of such size and weight that it could only be transported on and off the stage being powered by a hovercraft underneath it. If this wasn’t enough of a worry, the bill for this revolutionary instrument certainly would have set the alarm bells ringing among the Premier and his close staff. I can’t remember the exact figure, but was about $500K, something like $400K over what had been budgeted for it. In those days, that was a huge overspend, which neither his public service advisers nor his political ones could justify. Vivid memories of how the NSW Labor government was hammered for years about the overspend at the Opera House. It became a major political football, largely because the populist-style Cahill govt had been very shy in admitting the real cost of the Utzon masterpiece. Davis Hughes, the Minister in the incoming Askin Liberal-Country Party, had made much capital complaining about it and the delays when in Opposition. He did not stop when becoming Minister and it led to near-disaster when Utzon was sacked. There was no way Dunstan would let that happen. But it went against his rules to interfere.

I’m glad it is now 45 years on. I no longer feel obliged under Public Service rules to keep confidentiality. His solution to this dilemma was incredible. He contacted a professional fundraiser in Sydney. What they worked out was that Don Dunstan would give two special fundraising talks. Essentially, they’d be about what he had achieved during his time as Premier and how it had changed South Australia and its people.

The fundraiser contacted me. What he wanted was some secretarial assistance as he went about asking people to the first and second luncheons. It would be our phone number which subscribers would call to book seats. As our senior receptionist usually took the first phone call anyway, it was sensible to give her the task. She needed to log names, companies and phone numbers of those attending. Then she would give those details to the fundraiser for any of the follow-up and payments. It took quite a bit of her time, but she was thorough.

Don Dunstan was a celebrity in Sydney. He’d been known before he became SA Premier due to his popular television show. But the dazzling array of achievements during what became known as the Dunstan Decade was enviable to all interested in a fairer, more reasonable society. Adelaide, which functioned almost like Ancient Athens as a City-State, was suddenly a civilised place to be. He even coaxed Robert Helpmann back to direct one Festival. He in turn got his friend Rudolph Nureyev to perform. Don was famed for setting style in appearance (once wearing pink shorts into parliament) and his good looks and eloquent voice. Don Dunstan even performed at one Festival. At the Adelaide Zoo, supported by the SA Symphony Orchestra with live animals, he recited Ogden Nash’s poems to the Orchestra playing Saint-Saëns’ Carnival of the Animals. At the nearby Botanic Gardens, SA’s Chief Justice Dr Bray recited his own poems. It was that sort of place. 

From memory both lunches were oversubscribed. Payment for that organ was now by subscription not public money. The fundraiser was paid a commission on the amount raised. Our receptionist received a huge bunch of flowers for her trouble. The only public expense was the receptionist’s work and telephones, and air fares for Don to come to Sydney twice. But those would’ve been amply repaid by publicity to Don’s public speeches on both occasions. The people attending would not easily have forgotten. To me, it seemed a win-win situation. The Arts people would have their organ. The SA taxpayers would not be slugged an outrageous sum for a world-rated instrument that cost too much for such a rarely-used asset. Dunstan was able to avoid any accusations of waste. SA and its Premier got some publicity for a minimal cost. The donors got their money’s worth. Only Philistine politics missed out.

190 thoughts on “The Festival Hall Organ

  1. The limited bandwidth of the public’s attention is getting filled with the Novax ‘drama’. Novax working a treat for Bullshit Man.

  2. There seems to be a Twitter belief that Mick Fuller, NSW Police Commissioner (until April, when he hands over the job to Karen Webb) is a member of Hillsong.

    There is no evidence for that. Pentecostals talk constantly about their “faith” (as does Scovid). Fuller has never said a word about whatever church he attends or if he attends any at all..

    Previous NSW Police Commissioner Andrew Scipione, had very close links to Hillsong and made no secret of that. Maybe that is where all these rumours began.

    Living next door to Scovid does not make anyone a Pentecostal or other variety of evangelical. If Mick Fuller is a member of one of these cults then it’s not Hillsong. It’s more likely to be Scovid’s church, Horizon, at Sutherland, or some other happy-clapper “church” in The Shire. Even then it is extremely unlikely.

    Never believe anything you read on Twitter or other social media unless you know it is factual and you have seen proof.

  3. More examples of the feds stealing RATs ordered by private businesses –

    And from Lismore –
    Local pharmacy left high and dry as government ‘confiscates’ Rapid Antigen Tests
    https://lismoreapp.com.au/news-sport/news/local-pharmacy-left-high-and-dry-as-government-confiscates-rapid-antigen-tests?id=61dbae971096ef002c123bec

    • How short sighted . . . .

      Burra Foods is a dairy processor Gippsland – vital part of food chain?

      Lismore is the base hospital for the out of control covid cluster centred around tourist mecca Byron Bay and the anti-vax hinterland

    • From

    • But he will demand it from you because ‘I am the Prime Minister!!!’

      As evidenced by the ‘red carpet’ fiasco.

      Excellent point leonetwo

  4. Australian teachers plead for delayed school start as country faces COVID-19 peak
    NSW and Victoria are forging on to get students back to school on schedule, but teachers in those states feel their voices have been ignored as COVID-19 cases remain at high levels.
    https://www.sbs.com.au/news/australian-teachers-plead-for-delayed-school-start-as-country-faces-covid-19-peak/fd563c88-055e-4c2e-aa99-676495b2ca53

    I’ve said this before – if I had school age kids I’d be keeping them at home until they were fully vaccinated and if necessary, boosted.

    Why are we sacrificing our children by insisting they return to school before they are fully vaccinated?

    The gap between the first and second doses of a vaccine, according to Commonwealth Dept of Health advice is eight weeks –

    Children aged 5 to 11 years need 2 doses of Pfizer for children (one third the adult dose), given 8 weeks apart unless advised by a medical professional.

    You may not be fully protected against COVID-19 until 7 to 14 days after your second dose

    https://www.health.gov.au/initiatives-and-programs/covid-19-vaccines/approved-vaccines/pfizer

    Many children start school before they are are five and may wait months for that birthday. What happens to them?

  5. Good morning Dawn Patrollers. It was a feast yesterday, but a famine today!

    The SMAge outlines what Djokovic’s defence will be this morning as he fronts the full bench of the Federal Court.
    https://www.smh.com.au/sport/this-is-orwellian-djokovic-defence-emerges-ahead-of-court-hearing-20220115-p59oho.html
    These immigration law specialists say that Novak Djokovic’s chances are slim, but anything can happen in court.
    https://www.smh.com.au/sport/tennis/novak-djokovic-s-chances-are-slim-but-anything-can-happen-in-court-20220114-p59od6.html
    An exclusive survey for the SMAge shows 71 per cent of Australians think the defending Australian Open men’s champion should not be allowed to stay and compete.
    https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/send-him-home-poll-reveals-overwhelming-support-for-decision-to-deport-novak-djokovic-20220115-p59oh9.html
    The tennis star’s counsel spoke in support of a full bench earlier today, but the move was opposed by the government’s lawyers as it would remove both parties’ right to appeal.
    https://www.smh.com.au/sport/tennis/live-novak-djokovic-federal-court-appeal-set-for-sunday-after-immigration-minister-cancels-tennis-star-s-visa-ahead-of-2022-australian-open-20220115-p59ofk.html
    Meanwhile, at an ant-vax rally yesterday, Craig Kelly has called tennis player Novak Djokovic “a political prisoner of the Morrison regime”.
    https://www.smh.com.au/national/craig-kelly-calls-novak-djokovic-a-political-prisoner-at-anti-vax-rally-20220115-p59oh8.html
    The Djokovic match has Lucinda Price glued to her seat.
    https://www.smh.com.au/sport/tennis/djokovic-match-has-me-glued-to-my-seat-20220114-p59odc.html
    Andrew Leigh writes that charities are sick of fighting off attacks by the Morrison government.
    https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/jan/15/charities-are-sick-of-fighting-off-attacks-by-the-morrison-government
    Neoliberalism and poor government management over the years have been detrimental to a flourishing economy, writes Kyle Mervin.
    https://independentaustralia.net/politics/politics-display/government-greed-is-ruining-our-economy,15941
    Professor Stephen Faux describes the far-reaching effects Omicron is having on our health system and those who rely on it. Quite concerning, really.
    https://www.smh.com.au/national/patients-want-to-give-up-their-hospital-beds-politicians-need-to-help-them-do-it-20220109-p59mxx.html
    His infection illness has provided frontline health worker Professor Paul Komesaroff with the opportunity to reflect on our current predicament and what lessons can be learnt from it. It is rather an angry contribution where he squarely levels a lot of blame at Morrison and Perrottet.
    https://www.smh.com.au/national/the-crisis-forces-us-to-consider-what-kind-of-society-we-want-to-have-20220113-p59nzt.html

    Cartoon Corner

    Peter Broelman

    Reg Lynch

    Matt Golding

    Glen Le Lievre

    From the US






  6. Recommend Paul Komasaroff’s opinion pieve

    It seemed quick but in reality the forces had been in play all along. An unrelenting campaign to undermine the collective purpose, to oppose all restrictions, had worn away at confidence in public health measures. Campaigns of disinformation and conspiracy theories . . . . . were in reality a device to undermine prized individual “freedoms” hit home.

    https://www.smh.com.au/national/the-crisis-forces-us-to-consider-what-kind-of-society-we-want-to-have-20220113-p59nzt.html

  7. How loud was the eruption ? Tonga – Fiji 800km
    .
    .
    The Ratu SeruFlag of Fiji@MrCombs679
    ·15h Around 5pm today in Ravitaki village, Fiji. Capturing the sound of volcano eruption from Tonga vc:- Ana Naisoro

  8. Just an example of the types attracted to the Muckudda Camp –

  9. How come an arsehole – a rich arsehole at that – can get the Federal Court to sit on a Sunday morning two days after his visa was cancelled (again) while us plebs have to wait months, even years, for an initial hearing?

  10. This is a reply to Puff’s comments concerning my memoir from the Don Dunstan era. I posted it as a direct reply and thanks to Puffy, but for some reason WordPress wouldn’t accept. Now I can’t find her original comment to have another go! So I’ve copied my attempt again and will try again to post it now.
    Thanks for that, Puff.
    During the Dunstan Decade I was a fairly junior manager with SA Tourism in Sydney. At times I feel like that final scene in Camelot where things are in a burning ruin, King Arthur on his final legs. Then he turns to a servant boy and says, “You must flee, boy, but stay alive. You must tell the world that once there WAS a Camelot.” I feel at times I am that young boy, the last survivor of that era. I will try to keep it going with occasional stories such as that one. We can do better if we know it. Regards

  11. leonetwo, I was wondering about your comment – my first thought that was that I was back from one of my long ago ‘lost weekends’ of the last century as I turned on ABC News this morning. With no Barry Cassidy and “Insiders” to start my ‘normal’ Sunday there was no one there to anchor me in time. Can’t we somehow get back to how it used to be in the old days? I feel very uneasy when told I have to get used to the ‘new’ normal. Can someone explain to me how what has always been ‘normal’ has now changed into something ‘new’? Way back in the the old days I listened to the news and learned as grown ups explained to me that money doesn’t really talk! It just helps to get things done more quickly for some people who have lots of it than for the rest of us. I understood it then, and still do. It’s just normal! So what’s changed? What’s new?

    • PS leonetwo, my last comment was an accidental posting of my rambling thoughts in response to your asking how rich arseholes get special treatment, like Sunday morning high court hearings. It’s a long established law and very old known lore that money talks. The more you have, the more it works for you for and gets many things done! Even priority listing of legal process can be bought.

      ‘Affluence means influence!’ – the more literate might say, rather than crass things like ‘Money talks!’

    • I think it is because after almost a decade of Liberal misrule almost everyone has been brainwashed into believing money and having plenty of it is all that matters. Those who have no money are despised by the feds. That attitude, unfortunately, has rubbed off onto too many Australians

  12. Paywalled but Adams oh so right.

    Why we always get the wrong political leaders — and how to get the right ones

    Power attracts those most likely to abuse it and then makes them worse. So how do we stop voting for narcissistic psychopaths?

    Brian Klaas Saturday January 15 The Sunday Times

    Douglas Adams once wrote of a planet on which humans are ruled by lizard overlords. There’s a paradox: the planet is a democracy, the humans hate and outnumber the lizards and yet the lizards always get elected. It turns out the humans vote for the lizards for a simple reason: “If they didn’t … the wrong lizard might get in.”

    Maybe, just maybe, that planet is closer to Earth than we’d like to admit.

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/why-we-always-get-the-wrong-political-leaders-and-how-to-get-the-right-ones-27z7z3mcn

  13. How the hell would he know?!

    Health minister Greg Hunt says there are clear signs that the spread of the Omicron variant of the coronavirus is peaking.

    His prediction came as tens of thousands of Australians continued to be struck by the highly infectious strain and the death toll continued to climb.

    “There are signs that NSW in particular and the ACT may be peaking,” Hunt told reporters in Canberra on Sunday.

    https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2022/jan/16/australia-covid-update-greg-hunt-says-omicron-may-be-peaking-as-nsw-warned-difficult-three-weeks-ahead

  14. Christ Al-freaking-Mighty!

    How about this for stupidity! Major SA abattoir – one that supplies Woolworths, for God’s sake – forced Covid-positive workers to go to work until the abattoir had to be closed because so many staff were sick.

    Greedy bastards!

    Unions say exemption to allow Covid-positive people to work at SA meatworks sets ‘dangerous precedent’
    Workers who tested positive to Covid were forced to wear yellow hairnets to identify themselves
    https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2022/jan/15/unions-say-exemption-to-allow-covid-positive-people-to-work-at-sa-meatworks-sets-dangerous-precedent

  15. A good read

    The Novak Djokovic case has less to do with the tennis star himself and more to do with politics and how far a government is prepared to push the rules, indeed the independence of the Court, when the legal system is not working just as it would like.

    Four things stand out in the government’s campaign to undermine the rule of law:

    . a convenient “minister swap” from Karen Andrews to Alex Hawke,
    . Hawke keeping his decision secret for four days,
    . the government’s fragile pretext that Djokovic might arouse anti-vax sentiment,
    . and a judiciary prepared for a government which would play politics with the Court.

    Only the most ardent acolytes of the Coalition would agree with Prime Minister Scott Morrison’s claim to hold dear to rules. He might have said “rules are rules … no one is above these rules”, but his is a government prepared to subvert rules at any opportunity for political gain.

    And it is fair to say that, in this instance, a sacred rule of democracy – that is, the independence of the judiciary from executive government – has come under attack.

    https://www.michaelwest.com.au/government-sabotages-rule-of-law-in-djokovic-case-for-political-advantage/

  16. Not sure if it’s already been linked, but, probably not looking good for ScoMo and Domicron if a normally apolitical youtuber devoted to cars and auto makes a rant against them like this, and his audience being largely supportive from what I can tell.

  17. Well done Crow Eaters.
    .
    .
    South Australia breaks record by running for a week on renewable energy

    South Australia sourced an average of just over 100 per cent of the electricity it needed from renewable power for 6½ days leading up to December 29 last year – a record for the state and perhaps for comparable energy grids around the world.
    https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/environment/climate-change/south-australia-breaks-record-running-for-a-week-on-renewable-energy-20220116-p59omi.html

  18. Google translation from what is described as one of Serbia’s most popular paper. Don’t think they are happy with Bullshit Man.

    IS IT POSSIBLE THAT HE SAID THIS? The Prime Minister of Australia sent a shameful message after the expulsion of Novak: It is time to enjoy.

    Scott Morrison, the Prime Minister of Australia, managed to appear before the public again and send, to say the least, a shameful statement to the world.

    https://sport.blic.rs/tenis/da-li-je-moguce-da-je-ovo-rekao-premijer-australije-poslao-sramnu-poruku-posle/n8c2q29

Leave a Reply to leonetwo Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s